
You paid for a website, it went live, and since then it has mostly just sat there. The phone rings sometimes, but you cannot tell whether the site is bringing in work or quietly turning people away. If you have ever wondered whether your website is holding you back, this post is the 15-minute check that answers it. It is written for busy owners in and around Effingham, not for developers: every test here can be done on your phone, tonight, for free. By the end you will know whether your site is fine, fixable, or actively costing you customers, and what each of those outcomes should cost to deal with.
TL;DR: Run five checks: open your site on your phone, run a free speed test, Google your own business, submit your own contact form, and read your site for stale facts. If two or more fail, your website is holding you back. A free website review will tell you exactly what to fix and what it costs.
In this post:
- The five-minute phone test
- Run a free speed test
- Google your own business
- Send yourself a message
- Check whether your site still tells the truth
- What to do with what you found
- Frequently asked questions
The five-minute phone test
Most of your visitors are not on a computer. Mobile devices account for roughly 60% of web traffic worldwide, according to StatCounter, and for a local business searching “near me” from a parking lot, the share is higher still. So test your site the way customers actually see it: pull out your phone, open your site over cell data (not your office Wi-Fi), and act like a stranger.
Give yourself five seconds on the homepage. Can you tell what the business does, where it is, and how to contact it? Now try to do the three things a customer would do: find your hours, find a price or at least a starting point, and tap the phone number. If the number is not tappable, if you have to pinch and zoom to read anything, or if a popup covers the screen, you just watched a customer leave.
Run a free speed test
Speed is the least visible problem and one of the most expensive. A study by Deloitte and Google found that improving mobile site speed by just 0.1 seconds raised retail conversions by 8.4% (Milliseconds make millions). The effect runs the other way too: every extra second of loading is people giving up before they ever see your work.
Testing it costs nothing. Go to PageSpeed Insights, paste in your homepage address, and look at the mobile score. Above 90 is healthy. Between 50 and 90 means there is real money being left on the table. Below 50 means your site is slow enough that Google notices and so do your customers. Slow sites are usually a hosting problem, a bloated page-builder theme, or both. Cheap shared hosting is often the single biggest culprit, which is why our managed hosting plans start at $40/mo and target load times under two seconds.
Google your own business
Open a private or incognito browser window and search for your business by name, then search for what you do plus your town (“plumber Effingham IL”). Three things should be true. Your website shows up when someone searches your name. Your Google Business Profile appears with the right hours, address, and phone number. And your site appears somewhere reasonable for at least one “what you do + where” search.
If your own name search shows a Facebook page or an old directory listing above your website, people are getting their first impression somewhere you do not control. If the business profile shows wrong hours, customers are showing up to locked doors and blaming you. None of this requires a rebuild to fix, but it does need to be found before it can be fixed.
Send yourself a message
This one surprises more owners than any other check. Go to your own contact form, fill it out like a customer, and hit send. Then wait. Did the message arrive in an inbox someone actually reads? Today, not in the spam folder, not to an email address of an employee who left two years ago?
Contact forms fail silently. A plugin update breaks the email handoff, the hosting company changes a mail setting, and from that day forward every lead goes nowhere while the site looks perfectly fine. We have seen sites that lost months of inquiries this way. If your form test fails, treat it as urgent: it is the one problem on this list that costs you customers who had already decided to reach out.
Check whether your site still tells the truth
Read your site the way a stranger would and look for anything that is no longer true. Old prices. Services you stopped offering. A “news” section where the newest item is from three years ago. Staff photos with people who left. A copyright year in the footer from two site redesigns ago.
Stale facts do two kinds of damage. The obvious kind is a customer calling about a price you have not charged in years. The quiet kind is trust: when a visitor spots one outdated detail, they start doubting everything else on the page, including whether you are still in business. A website only works if keeping it current is somebody’s actual job, whether that somebody is you, an employee, or us.
What to do with what you found
Score yourself honestly. Five passes means your website is not the problem, and your time is better spent on reviews, Google Business Profile posts, and asking happy customers to spread the word. One or two failures usually means targeted fixes: better hosting, a form repair, a content update. You should not be quoted a full rebuild for a broken contact form.
Three or more failures means the site is holding you back, and patching it piece by piece tends to cost more than addressing it properly. There are two honest paths from there. Pay once for a proper rebuild, or move to a flat monthly arrangement where the site, the hosting, the security, and the updates are all one person’s job. Our website subscription does exactly that for $299/mo, including content changes within two business days, and you own the site at the end of the term.
Either way, start with facts instead of a sales pitch. Our free website review runs these checks and more against your site and sends you the results in plain English. No obligation, and if the review says your site is fine, we will tell you that too.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my website is costing me customers?
Run five checks: open the site on your phone over cell data, run Google’s free PageSpeed Insights test, search your business name in an incognito window, submit your own contact form, and read every page for outdated facts. Two or more failures means the site is actively losing you business.
What is a good load time for a small business website?
Under two seconds on a phone is the target. Deloitte and Google research found that even a 0.1 second improvement in mobile speed lifted retail conversions by 8.4%, so small gains matter. If PageSpeed Insights scores your mobile site below 50, speed is likely your biggest problem.
My website looks fine on my computer. Is that enough?
No. Roughly 60% of web traffic is mobile, and local customers searching on the go push that higher. A site that looks fine on a desktop can still have tiny tap targets, unreadable text, and slow load times on a phone. Always judge your site by its mobile experience first.
How often should a website be updated?
Software updates (WordPress core, plugins, security patches) should happen at least monthly. Content should be reviewed quarterly: hours, prices, services, and staff. If nobody has touched your site in over a year, assume something is broken or out of date, because something almost always is.
Do I need a new website or can mine be fixed?
It depends on what failed. A broken form, slow hosting, or stale content can usually be fixed for far less than a rebuild. If the site fails most of the checks, is built on an abandoned theme, or cannot be edited safely, a rebuild or a $299/mo subscription is usually cheaper than endless patching.
How much does it cost to find out what is wrong with my website?
Nothing. The checks in this post are free and take about 15 minutes. If you want a professional pass, DietzenDev offers a free website review with no obligation: we test speed, mobile experience, search visibility, and forms, then send you the findings in plain English, whatever you decide to do next.
The bottom line
You do not need a developer to tell whether your website is holding you back. Fifteen minutes, your phone, and five honest checks will tell you. If the site passes, carry on. If it fails, you now know exactly where, which means nobody can sell you a fix you do not need. And if you would rather have a second set of eyes on it, request a free website review and we will run the full version of these checks for you this week.